Scheme to reduce disturbance to waterfowl during severe winter weather

 

For up-to-date info on Voluntary Restraints:  BASC website

 

For latest winter weather data:  Met Office data  [access restricted by password]

 

What is the scheme?

This scheme (which runs from 9 November to 20 February) is designed to help with conservation of waterfowl; ducks, geese, and waders, by reducing disturbance to them during periods of prolonged cold weather. Shooting organisations co-operate closely with voluntary and statutory nature conservation organisations to minimise disturbance to birds during such severe weather. The season for waterfowl shooting inland closes on 1 February and for foreshore shooting it closes on 21 February. However, the relevant Secretary of State(s) has power to impose a temporary close season of waterfowl shooting during ‘severe weather’ (Wildlife and Countryside Act Section 2).  This scheme provides an agreed process as to what qualifies as ‘severe weather’. In addition to providing criteria for a statutory suspension of shooting, criteria have been agreed for periods of less prolonged severe weather, where voluntary restraint of shooting will be encouraged where appropriate.  Other sources of disturbance in cold weather should also be reduced, and bird watchers, bird ringers, walkers, dog-walkers, horse-riders and water-based sports, in particular, should avoid disturbing groups of feeding or resting birds.

Why is it needed?

For many species of bird, and especially for waterfowl, mid-winter can be an ecological "bottle-neck" when they have difficulty obtaining enough food, particularly in severe cold weather when the ground becomes frozen. They face reduced prospects for survival during such times. In addition, many waterfowl will have flown to Britain to escape from even colder conditions in continental Europe. Lengthy spells of cold weather result in many birds showing changed behaviour. They become "tame" and reluctant to fly when approached in order to avoid using up their remaining energy reserves. In these circumstances, it is important to reduce any disturbance, such as that caused by waterfowl shooting, because when the birds cease feeding and fly around, they use up their limited energy reserves more quickly. When several periods of severe weather occur within a short time scale, voluntary restraints play a particularly important role because it allows populations to recover from stress.

What does this mean for waterfowl shooters?

  • Once severe weather fulfils previously agreed criteria and there appears to be no sign of a change the British Association of Shooting and Conservation (BASC) normally calls on waterfowl shooters to exercise voluntary restraint in shooting where appropriate.
  • Once stricter criteria are met, a statutory suspension comes into force. This prohibits the shooting of any bird on Schedule 2 Part 1 of the Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981; in effect it introduces a temporary close season for these birds. This applies throughout the specified country, affecting all inland and coastal waterfowl shooting. This suspension will be widely publicised through the media.
  • During both periods of voluntary restraint and statutory suspension of shooting, waterfowl shooters, and all who use the countryside, are encouraged to provide information on the conditions of birds and habitats by completing bird condition forms. This allows us to better assess how the weather is affecting birds and identify the most appropriate action to take. 

Agreed Criteria

The following guidelines have been agreed among the statutory country conservation agencies, government departments and non-governmental organisations, for example, the RSPB, WWT and BASC. In this scheme, England and Wales are dealt with as a single ecological management unit, separately from Scotland. The reason for this is because within Great Britain, birds tend to move westwards (as well as south) with the Welsh coast often receiving birds displaced from the frozen eastern coast of England.  It is therefore logical to consider Wales and England as a single management unit.


The Met Office records temperature data at network of 25 meteorological stations throughout England, Scotland and Wales on a daily basis (Table 1 and map). These stations are chosen to reflect broadly the weather conditions around the coast and are often close to major estuaries and centres of foreshore shooting.

 

Table 1. Primary and Secondary SWO weather stations for Scotland, England/Wales
  Primary Station  Station number  Secondary Station  Station number
Scotland (9)        
West (5) Aultbea 03034 Skye Lusa  03037
  Tiree  03100  South Uist  03026
  Islay (Port Ellen)  03105   Machrihanish 03111
  Prestwick 03136  Auchincruive  99088
  Dundrennan   03153 West Freugh  03132
 East (4)  Edinburgh - Gogarbank   03166 Edinburgh RBG  99180
  Wick Airport    03075 Tain Range  03062
  Aberdeen (Dyce)    03091 Craibstone 99133
  Lossiemouth   03068  Rosehearty 03094
         
England and Wales (16)        
 North West (4)  Walney Island   03214  St Bees Head  03210
  Crosby     03316 Rhyl 03313
  Valley    03302  Aberdaron 03405
  Gogerddan     99150 Porthmadog 99163
 South West (6)  Milford Haven     03604 Aberporth 03502
  St Athan    03716 Mumbles Head  03609
  Isle of Portland     03857 Swanage  99159
  Chivenor     03808 Cambourne 03809
  Culdrose     03809 Plymouth 03827
 
  Thorney Island    03872 Bournemouth (Hurn)   03862
 South East (3)  Herstmonceux     03882  Manston  03797
  Shoeburyness     03693 Manston 03797
 
  Cromer     99122 Holbeach 03469
 North East (3)  Wainfleet     03392 Bridlington 03292
  Loftus     03275 Scarborough  99142
  Boulmer     03240 Albermarle 03238

 

NB. From time-to-time sites open and close, and the Met Office will undertake reasonable endeavours during the service to retain continuity of service.

Figure 1. Primary and Secondary SWO weather stations for Scotland and England-Wales

 

When more than half of these meteorological stations (in Scotland and/or England/Wales) have recorded frozen conditions (determined from minimum air and grass temperatures) for seven consecutive days (but allowing short periods of thaw), the country conservation agencies liaise with BASC who normally advise a period of voluntary restraint of shooting where appropriate whilst severe weather conditions last.

 

On the 13th day of frozen conditions, if more than half the relevant meteorological stations are still frozen, a case is presented to the relevant Secretary of State(s) requesting a suspension on waterfowl shooting due to the severe weather. Such suspensions can be instituted in Scotland alone, and/or in England/Wales dependent on the extent of the cold weather. Once the Statutory Instrument has been signed, it comes into force at 00h01, two days after the case was presented.

 

With respect to the agreed process of counting days of severe weather, short periods of thaw (one or two days with less than half stations frozen) have no effect on the counting process, but periods of thaw of three or more days have the effect of resetting the severe weather day number to 0. Such short periods of thaw are 'neutral' in terms of counting days towards a suspension - that is they neither count nor terminate the process.

Publicising restraint and suspension

Calls for voluntary restraint of waterfowl shooting will be publicised by BASC and the relevant country-based statutory nature conservation organisations. Other organisations who are party to the scheme may also publicise such events. In addition, BASC will email all its wildfowling clubs and shooting syndicates calling for voluntary restraint in waterbird shooting in those parts of the country where necessary (and warning of the possibility of a statutory suspension if conditions persist).

 

Once a case has been presented to the Secretary of State(s) advising of a statutory suspension of waterfowl shooting, the impending suspension will be publicised widely. BASC will inform all its wildfowling club secretaries, Joint Councils and game shooting syndicates, and it will institute a 24-hour telephone information service in all regions of the country. Defra, Scottish Government, Welsh Government, JNCC and relevant country-based statutory nature conservation organisations will publicise statutory suspensions on their websites. Other organisations who are party to the scheme are likely to do the same. In accordance with Section 26(5) of the Act, when the suspension affects England and Wales an advertisement is placed in the London Gazette.

How long does the suspension last?

A statutory suspension of waterfowl shooting is for an initial period of 14 days. The suspension is examined after seven days. If the weather conditions have improved and the forecast is for a continuation of this improvement, then, in consideration with other factors, the lifting of the suspension can be recommended. However, if there has been no thaw and the weather is still severe then the statutory suspension continues for the full 14 days.

 

Any lifting of the suspension before the full 14 days will take into consideration the need for a period of recovery for waterbirds after the end of the severe weather itself. In this event, DEFRA, Welsh Government and/or Scottish Government undertake publicity campaigns as extensively as possible to inform the shooting community of the fact.

 

There can be an extension of the statutory suspension beyond 14 days, through the signing of a second Statutory Instrument, if there is still severe weather and no improvement in weather conditions is forecast. The management of the second period of suspension is undertaken in the same manner as the first. Information on the condition of waterfowl should continue to be reported through completion of the bird condition form to aid review.

The role of conservation staff

Country Conservation Agency contacts (see principle organisational contacts below) are responsible for agreeing with BASC if a period of voluntary restraint is required once the seventh day of severe weather is reached. The country conservation agency contacts should also liaise with their respective government, and, in the event of an imminent statutory suspension, have the responsibility to provide them with formal advice to implement the statutory suspension.

 

A network of representatives from the Country Conservation Agencies, shooting and game keeping associations and various conservation organisations are alerted by the Met Office of periods of severe weather. It is their responsibility to disseminate this information to their regional staff, shooting clubs and syndicates and other users of waterfowl habitat, to encourage them to minimise disturbance to birds and to provide feedback on local conditions by completing the bird condition forms available to download on this website.  They should pay particular attention not only to the foreshore and freezing of inland waters and feeding grounds, but also to the condition of birds, bird numbers and movements, appearance of unusual species, significance of wind chill and to snow cover.

 

An important role of conservation staff is the publicising and encouraging of compliance with any call for voluntary restraint, or statutory suspension. In addition it is very important for them to encourage reduction of other forms of disturbance, for example bird watching, bird ringing, walking, dog-walking, horse-riding and water-based sports. Conservation staff should raise awareness of this where possible, and consider altering access routes in particularly vulnerable areas.  

Further information

A review of the historical background to the current system of cold weather shooting bans was published in "Statutory Suspension of Wildfowling in Severe Weather, Review of past winter weather and actions" JNCC Report No. 75. This gives detailed information on the operation and efficiency of the scheme in previous winters.

Principal organisational contact points

If you have any further queries regarding these waterfowl shooting suspensions, please contact either the relevant Country Agency contact or JNCC (see table below).

 

Name Organisation Telephone Email
Ed Mountford1 JNCC 01733 866917
Matt Murphy Cyfoeth Naturiol Cymru/Natural Resources Wales 01248 387264
Nigel Shelton Natural England 03000 600039
Andrew Douse Scottish Natural Heritage 01463 725000
Paul Williamson British Association for Shooting and Conservation 01244 573000
Nigel Clark British Trust for Ornithology 01842 750050
Neil Douglas RSPB 01767 693006
Richard Hearn  Wildfowl & Wetlands Trust 01453 891185
 
1 if unavailable: , JNCC; 01733 562626
 
Download bird condition observation form
  •  

  • Bird condition observation form:

Download Acrobat version (PDF, 24 kb)

Download Rich text format version ( 72 kb)

 

You will need the free Adobe Acrobat Reader to view this document.